Today’s post is a followup to a discussion we had a few weeks ago. The best colored pencils for fine art was the topic for that post. Today, let’s get specific and talk about the best pencil brands for fine art.
Let’s dive right in.
The Best Pencil Brands for Fine Art (In My Experience)
This article is not meant to be an in-depth review of every brand of pencil on the market. There are just too many pencils to make that possible in a single post.
So I’m going to briefly review the pencils that work well for the methods and papers I use. Your experiences may be different, but I hope this list gives you a place to begin looking for the best colored pencils for your art.
The list is alphabetical, not in order of preference.
Caran d’Ache Luminance
Caran d’Ache Luminance are some of the best colored pencils on the market. They are also more opaque than most other colored pencils, so you can draw light over dark more easily. It’s still best to start with light colors and layer darker colors over them, but you have a bit more flexibility with Luminance.
They are a well-made, thick lead pencil with a great variety of colors suitable for any subject. I especially like the collection of landscape and animal colors.
Many artists swear by these pencils, claiming they’re the best overall quality and performance of any other wax-based pencil on the market. That may very well be true.
My experience has been less positive. Yes, they are soft and creamy and all the colors are well-rated for lightfastness.
But my preferred papers are papers like UArt Premium Pastel Paper and Pastelmat. I’ve had limited success with Luminance on those papers.
That’s not to say they’re a bad pencil; they’re a very good pencil.
It just means they don’t work well for me.
Caran d’Ache Pablo
Caran d’Ache Pablo Pencils are a harder pencil than their cousins, Caran d’Ache Luminance. I have heard that they’re similar to Prismacolor Verithin, but I’ve found them to be somewhere between Prismacolor Premier and Faber-Castell Polychromos in feel and behavior.
They are wax-based, so they’re softer than oil-based pencils. But the formulation of the binding agent is different from that used for Luminance, so Pablo pencils are a bit drier and harder than Luminance.
The color selection is the same as with Luminance, and the pigment core is the same size. But the casings have flat sides. That’s ideal for keeping them from rolling off your drawing table or desk.
They work very well on their own, or in combination with Polychromos. I haven’t done much with them in combination with Prismacolor or other brands. But given their middle-of-the-road softness, they are a good fit for any other artist quality pencil.
I’ve been using them mostly on Pastelmat and like the way they lay down.
Derwent Drawing Colored Pencils
Derwent Drawing Colored Pencils specialize in muted tones. They’re perfect for animal and landscape art, but if you like bright, vibrant colors, you’ll have to find a second line of pencils.
These pencils are wax-based, and quite soft. But they’re thicker than most other colored pencils, so they don’t have the problems with breakage that you encounter with a lot of other wax-based pencils. Unfortunately, there are only 72 colors currently available, but if you love drawing animals or landscapes, it’s worth your money to add these to your pencil selection.
I have a set of 36 colors, and I do like the way they put down color. But so far, I used them mostly for sketching and doodling. As yet, I haven’t used them for more finished artwork. But they do work well with other wax-based pencils.
Faber-Castell Polychromos
Faber-Castell Polychromos are an excellent pencil for most methods of drawing. They sharpen well, lay down color very nicely, and produce exquisite detail.
Polychromos pencils are oil-based with a harder pigment core than most wax-based pencils, so they handle differently than wax-based pencils. In my experience, I feel more resistance between pencil and paper when using Polychromos on smooth paper. But I can do more with them than with Prismacolor on rougher papers like Canson Mi-Teintes or sanded art papers.
Prismacolor and Polychromos work well together. I suggest putting down Polychromos pencils for the initial layers, then coming back with Prismacolor for detail work.
The initial cost is higher per pencil for Polychromos than Prismacolor. But you get higher quality, more lightfast colors, and pencils that go further than the softer Prismacolor pencils.
The range of earth tones is also a treat for an artist like me, who prefers drawing horses and landscapes.
Prismacolor Premier & Verithin
I still use Prismacolor Premier and Verithin pencils for a lot of work. They’re what I learned with, and I love the way they glide onto Stonehenge paper.
Both pencils are wax-based. Prismacolor Premier is a softer pencil with a thicker pigment core. You can lay down rich color more easily with these than with the Verithin pencils. But you will also find yourself sharpening more often. Prismacolor pencils also fill up paper tooth more quickly.
The Verithin pencils have a smaller pigment core that holds a point much longer and is ideal for first color layers and drawing details. It’s not impossible to get deep, rich color with them, but it is more difficult. The biggest drawback to Verithin pencils is the color selection. There are only thirty-six colors, and not all of them are lightfast.
Both lay down color very well, and you can get a high degree of detail on a variety of papers, but quality issues can make buying them a risk.
The Bottom Line
There you have it. My recommendations as to the best colored pencil brands for fine art. As I said, it’s nowhere near an exhaustive list. But hopefully it gives you a place to begin your own search for the ideal colored pencil.
Before you buy any pencil, do a little research. Look for honest and open reviews either on the product pages where you normally buy art supplies, or video reviews.
Then make your selections based on that information.
Want to know what I’d buy if I were just starting out? Dream Colored Pencil Shopping List.
Sign up for Carrie’s free weekly newsletter and be among the first to know when she publishes new articles.









